When Writing A Book, From Whom Should You Seek Advice?

//When Writing A Book, From Whom Should You Seek Advice?

When Writing A Book, From Whom Should You Seek Advice?

I love answering questions from my readers! Here’s why:

  1. I like to help people.
  2. I learn what’s important to my readers.


Let’s see if you can guess the hidden “lesson” from this question.


I was thrilled to get a new question from my new BFF, Ned Barnett, a fellow PR guy in Las Vegas. He wrote:

Good afternoon – I’d like to take a moment of your time to ask you a question about the direction of my forthcoming book, which is in its final editing stage.  I’m in a bit of a should-I/shouldn’t-I dilemma, and I’d welcome your insights.

A few weeks ago, I read a portion of my forthcoming book, “Write Now!,” to a writer’s group, and one member suggested that I transform it into a writing “course” (in book form). Initially, I thought that was a great idea, but now, I’m having second thoughts, so I’d like your opinion.

Write Now! was created to do several things including to demonstrate how books can help writers make money beyond traditional royalty income – including helping to land clients, secure profitable speaking gigs, serve as highly-paid expert witnesses in legal cases, and even appear as an expert in the news media.

Having taught writing and promotion at four colleges and universities, I’d have no problem turning this into a course in book format … and while I could see people who are already writers seeing benefits in a course, I am having a hard time seeing the target markets I noted above wanting a course if they weren’t already presold on the benefits of a book.

So … I ask your insights … does it make sense to transform this into a course in book format, or leave it as a how-to book?

Ned Barnett, APR

Marketing & PR Fellow, American Hospital Association

Barnett Marketing Communications


What would say to Ned?

Here’s how I replied:


Hi Ned,


You are talking about TWO products. Write the book. Upsell to a course.

In fact, upsell to everything, but you know that.

Your friend is way too binary (either/or).

Good luck!


Ned replied:

Wow – exactly what I need and didn’t see … and oddly, I’ve got a sort-of sample on my shelf:  New York Literary Agent Donald Maass’ book on writing a block buster, and his companion workbook (which could just as easily be an online course).  Color me “Duh!” … This is great help, Dan. Thanks!

Have you guessed the “hidden lesson?”

It’s “Ask advice from people you trust and respect!”

Don’t listen to opinions from people who have good intentions, but who are not experts. Listen to experts and seek their counsel.



By |2018-07-20T14:16:20+00:00July 19th, 2018|Book publishing|0 Comments

About the Author:

Dan Janal, author of "Write Your Book In A Flash!" helps leaders write books so they can get more clients and sell more products. My clients get terrific results from my coaching, developmental editing and ghostwriting. For info, go to http://www.WriteYourBookInAFlash.com.

Leave A Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Targeted Queries To Save You Time

We get hundreds of leads each day on dozens of topics. But we only send you leads in your specialty to save you time.

PR LEADS helps you:

  Save time
  Save money
  Reduce your stress
  Make getting publicity fun
  And, it's easy to use...
  We'll even train you!

The Easier Way To Get Publicity

PR LEADS has helped more than 4,000 business experts, solo PR firms, and small businesses. And we can help you get the publicity you need to:

  Build credibility
  Create marketing tools for your handouts and websites
  Position you as an expert
  Show why you are better and different from competitors
  Justify raising your rates and fees
  Grow your business
  Help your clients get publicity